• PT
  • ES
  • EN

CGI - Corporate Governance Institute

  • Home
  • All articles
    • Structure & Organization
    • Culture
    • Sustainability
    • Governance in large projects
    • Contracts, Risk and Compliancy
    • Impact of digitalization
    • Integrity
  • CGI information
  • Become an author!
  • Authors
  • Must read
    • Must read books
    • Articles and publications
  • FAQ
  • Contact

What’s the difference between Volkswagen and DeutscheBank?

December 3, 2019 By Hans-Martin Buhlmann Leave a Comment

Right answer! – nothing except their ISIN (International Securities Identification Number)

It was Rolf-E. Breuercon who set the ball rolling for DeutscheBank with an inept interview that triggered a ten-year-long stint of legal battles. In the end the bank was near on a billion Euros poorer in hard cash and loss of image, not even counting legal fees.

Volkwagen’s cause, by contrast, was served by a CEO who with disarming naïveté made a great show of ‘open mouth insert both feet’ during the North American International Auto Show in Detroit, plumbing unexplored depths of stupidity and gaucherie. It almost seemed that the higher you get on the salary scale, the more you tend to throw English overboard together with the instruction manual on how to turn the brain switch to the ‘on’ position before answering reporters’ questions.
http://www.npr.org/2016/01/13/462883613/vw-ceo-we-didnt-lie-about-emissions

“We didn’t lie. We didn’t understand the question “
“We had not the right interpretation of the American law “
was the truculent answer delivered by Volkswagen chief Matthias Müller when being questioned in a radio interview hosted by NPR (National Public Radio). If these were his own words he was badly out of line. If they were being fed to him, his choice of source was badly out of line.

When a CEO states that he didn’t understand a question that he gave an answer to, and forgets to get a clear grasp of the rules of compliance of a priority market before setting out to conquer it, the Supervisory Board ought to intervene to shield shareholders from further harm. Here’s hoping that the car manufacturer’s Supervisor Board makes great haste, much more than the bank did when it entrusted the flock to the safekeeping of the lone wolf.

Volkswagen’s skill in manoeuvring within scenarios of this kind leaves a lot to be desired. The Supervisory Board’s first move was to summon an extraordinary shareholders meeting for November 9, 2015. But then, the shareholders’ voting orientation seemed to be veering towards the unfavourable so the meeting was cancelled and the tribunal petitioned to appoint former CFO Hans Dieter Pötsch as new chair of the Supervisory Board. He seems to be above reproach but his involvement is considerable because of the ad hoc publication that constitutes the basis of the shareholders’ action.
I can already hear it (as rendered by Müller)

“We didn’t forget to disclose. We didn’t understand ad-hoc rules”
“we had not the right interpretation of German law”

The unobtrusive observer will woder how come? How come these people are on seven-figure salaries without ever having taken the time to read the German Civil Code? And what about this chairperson of the Supervisory Board, this irreproachable model of a durable conflict of interest, who will prep the CEO prior to being interviewed on the radio and debrief him afterwards. But what happens when a journalist from Bloomberg turns up at the front door with a bunch of awkward questions, like what happened to the bank. Perhaps the Supervisory Board would benefit from private tuition by Toshiba before lurching forwards with eyes wide shut just so as to complete the course. How about just setting up a common Supervisory Board for Toshiba and Volkswagen with the same members for both. That way, the hard knocks and waste of money would only happen once..
IMG_0929IR2014_Abschlussdiskussion_Buhlmann

 

Feel free to share:
  • Share via LinkedIn
  • Share via Twitter
  • Share via Google
  • Share via Facebook
  • Share via Tumblr
  • Share via Email
  • Share via WhatsApp

Filed Under: Culture, Governance in large projects, Sustainability Tagged With: Corporate governance, Deutschland, Europe

Read all articles (there's lots more on corporate governance)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All categories

  • Structure & Organization
  • News
  • Sustainability
  • Integrity
  • Culture
  • Governance in large projects
  • Contracts, Risk and Compliancy
  • Impact of digitalization

Advertisement

Recent articles

  • Corporate Reputation: It certainly matters
  • The Misconception About CEO Tenures
  • LEVERAGING THE ORGANISATION’S MEMORANDUM OF INCORPORATION TO IMPROVE IT’S RISK MANAGEMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY.
  • STARBUCKS CEO: WHAT’S THE ROLE AND RESPONSIBILITY OF A FOR-PROFIT COMPANY?
  • The Confluence, Ebb, and Flow of Leadership, Governance, and Management
  • Non-profit boards – how to be more effective
  • SOCIAL MEDIA – CHANGING TIMES AND INCREASING RISK
  • Auditor Remuneration in India: Trends and Insights
  • Corporate Social Responsibility in Banks
  • Bells set to toll for independent school governance
  • GDPR substantially changes the manner in which personal data is treated.
  • Manage For Trust Not Profits
  • Corporate Social Responsibility in Banks
  • Recognize a low trust organization, and reap the rewards of a high trust culture
  • The shifting sands of auditing should send signa to boards
  • REGULAR BOARD EVALUATION IS MORE THAN SIMPLY A RECOMMENDATION
  • WHY DO COMPANIES WALK ‘BACKWARDS INTO THE FUTURE’?
  • WHY NON-EXECUTIVES SHOULDN’T DO IT FOR THE FEES ALONE
  • Wall Street tries to weed out the wolves while London stays sheepish
  • Is your board dysfunctional?

Join the community

Please join our community. Become part of the corporate governance platform and start writing. Also join the LinkedIn group.

Newsletter subscription

Stay up to date on corporate governance. Get monthly updates. Subscribe here.

Corporate Governance Institute (CGI)

CGI is a world-wide platform to share and deliver knowledge about Corporate Governance (Public and Non-Public). In strong relation with our LinkedIn Group CGi we are a worldwide community that supports the relevance of good governance in general. These all with the right fit and respect to cultural pace and essential cultural differences.

Other pages

  • CGI worldwide partners
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertising

Search this website

Contact information

Please fill out our contact form or send an email to info@corgovinsitute.com

Copyright © 2019 · corgovinstitute.com · CGI owned by Nstrada Group · With ♡ by RaketNet

en English
ar العربيةzh-CN 简体中文nl Nederlandsen Englishfr Françaisde Deutschit Italianopt Portuguêsru Русскийes Español